|Sunday, April 20, 2014||
What Experts Say About Allowances for Children
Your six-year-old daughter
wants an allowance--all of her friends get one. You wonder if she's old enough to handle the money and,
if you give her one--how much should she get and how often? Before you know it she'll be asking
for a raise.
Allowances can help children understand the concept of budgeting and saving, but you have to teach
them. "A regular allowance helps kids take responsibility for spending decisions and encourages
independence. Instead of getting money 'on demand' whenever they need it, children with regular
allowances can learn to plan ahead--to anticipate spending needs and make choices about what's most
important," says Linda Boelter, a certified financial planner and family financial management
specialist at the University of Wisconsin-Extension.
If you're considering giving your child an allowance, here are several things to decide:
If you decide to give an allowance, start one as soon as your children start recognizing money's
worth--kids do this fairly early. Janet Bodnar, senior editor of Kiplinger's
personal finance magazine
in Washington, D.C., stresses two points in her book
"Dollars & Sense for Kids":
- Don't give an allowance until children are old enough to manage it. You don't have to give one
until your children are at least six years old. There's no need to rush things and preschoolers
generally don't understand the abstract idea of money anyway. Once children start first grade they
begin learning about money in school, so they know if they get a $1 bill each week, it's equivalent
in value to ten dimes or four quarters.
- Keep the system simple so you can manage it. "Denying kids an allowance doesn't make it easier to
limit the amount of money they get their hands on," says Bodnar. Because most children will get the
money out of parents anyway, it's better to teach them how to manage it themselves than allow them to
nickel and dime you to death. Plus, using an allowance gives parents and children more control over
the children's finances.
Give children enough of an allowance so they can squander it, but not so much that you'll be upset
when they do, recommends Bodnar. Sit down with your children and decide what expenses the allowance
will cover and try not to underestimate a kid's cost of living, she adds.
"Allowance doesn't depend on a family's financial situation to the degree you would think," says
Bodnar. It depends on how much money parents think kids need access to. Most kids have a limited
amount of things to spend money on--no matter what their family's financial situation is.
Ask others what they pay but go with your own instincts and values for what you believe is
appropriate. "Keep allowances reasonable," says Kaitlyn Laurie, child and adult psychotherapist in
Madison, Wis., and certified parent instructor for Parenting With Love and Logic--a series of classes
on parenting issues. "Overdoing it gives kids the impression that things come too easily; underdoing
it gives them the impression things come too hard."
Some parents give a weekly allowance equal to their child's age--but that can overcompensate younger
children, Bodnar says. And it's too rich for most parents. For six- to eight-year-olds, the average
allowance is about $4.80 a week, according to a recent Nickelodeon/Yankelovich Youth Monitor survey.
That rises to $7 for kids nine to 11 and $16.60 for 12- to 17-years-olds. Or, Bodnar suggests trying
an allowance equal to half your child's age.
- First-graders need at least $1 a week to do any serious spending or saving; even $2 isn't out of
line. As children get older, adjust the amount upward depending on what expenses you expect them to
- As kids age it's reasonable to pay them more. For example, besides movie tickets, you might expect
your 11-year-old to pay for snacks and games at the arcade, but figure that basic expenses for
clothing and school supplies are your responsibility.
- By the time children reach the age of 15, it's reasonable to expect them to contribute toward
clothes, movie tickets, and school activities such as ski trips.
Give children a
linked to chores
but linked to
You should pay allowances on a regular schedule. Weekly payments are best for younger children
because long-term gratification isn't their strongest suit. "As children get older, monthly payments
may be a better strategy--this is where budgeting skills come in," says Boelter. "If they spend it all
in the first week, it's gone," she says. "Teaching children to budget in their teen years helps save
them from the consequences of not knowing how to budget as they get older," she adds. "It's better to
not be able to go to the movies for a couple of weeks when you're 16 than not being able to pay rent
or a car payment when you're 25."
Whatever payment schedule you choose, stick to it. "Forgetting to pay an allowance does more harm
than not giving an allowance at all," says Boelter. "You need to model responsibility if you expect
your children to be responsible," she says.
One of the most controversial issues regarding allowances is whether you should expect children to do
chores in return. Child-development experts generally say no.
"There are risks in linking allowances to chores," says David Riley,
Bascom Professor of Human Ecology at the University of Wisconsin (Madison)-Extension. "It sounds like
a good idea at first because we want children to have experience actually working for money,"
he adds, "but, the problem is that it undercuts the idea of the family as a moral unit.
"For instance," Riley asks, "suppose you're giving your son an allowance for mowing the lawn, but
then your neighbor offers him slightly more for mowing his lawn .
Does that mean your son should
stop mowing your lawn and mow the neighbor's instead?
"If you think the family is a primary economic unit--like a business--then that's what your son should
do," says Riley. "But, the family isn't that. Parents should communicate to children that the reason
they need to do chores is not because they'll be rewarded with money, but because they are a family."
"Give children a basic allowance that isn't linked to chores but linked to spending
responsibilities," says Laurie. "This money is to teach them how to handle money," she adds.
However, Laurie also suggests giving children the opportunity to supplement their income by doing
Some parents pay children for good grades. This isn't a good idea either, according to Boelter.
Parents shouldn't bribe children or pay for performance, she says. "It undermines the kind of lessons
we want to teach our kids and becomes manipulative."
"Instead let children know how proud you are with extra hugs, words of encouragement, or special
treats such as stickers or a later bedtime--anything but money," says Kiplinger's Bodnar.
That way the virtue of doing homework or getting good grades becomes its own reward, and kids learn
the personal satisfaction that comes from doing a good job, she adds.
you have to
How do you get them to save?
"The point is to know your own kid's personality," says Bodnar, "and to realize that all kids respond
differently to money--even kids in the same family."
Bodnar says some kids will save on their own; in fact some are little hoarders--it's almost hard
to get them to spend money. These children may want
a share savings account
how to make their money grow. "In this case, you should respond to your child's lead and capitalize on
what he naturally wants to do," she says.
"Kids that don't want to save, will need extra encouragement," Bodnar says. Require them to save a
percentage of their allowance, but try to make saving fun. For example, have them save their money in
a fun piggy bank--something simple so they can see their money grow. When they save enough, help them
make their own purchases so they see themselves being rewarded, she says.
Kids need to save for something specific, according to Bodnar. If they are young they should be
saving for something very concrete--something they can realize in a short time. Start small. "Put them
in charge of the single thing they most like to spend your money on, whether it's comic books, video
arcade games, or popcorn at the movies," says Bodnar. Saving for short-term goals rewards them but
also teaches them they don't have to have everything right away.
For really young children, putting money in a savings account can mean out of sight, out of mind.
However, as they get a bit older, explain how accounts work and how interest makes savings grow.
Plus, at this point, they may have more money to put in the account.
"Another incentive is to match what they save," says Bodnar. This can motivate kids, especially if
they're saving for something costly. It gives them an incentive to accumulate a certain balance, she
Parents often want older teens to save for long-term goals--college, a new car, or a down payment on
a first house--but don't think they have the right to insist. Riley says parents have every right to
insist on saving. "It's the same as not allowing children to buy illegal items," he says.
And, Riley says, parents should involve their children in family decision-making about finances such
as purchasing a new vehicle or saving for a vacation. "If you're setting money aside for a long-term
goal such as buying a house or saving for retirement, involve your children. If money is doing well
in the stock market, let your children know so they learn about the stock market--be open about
enough so they
can squander it,
but not so much
that you'll be
Should you dock their pay?
Docking allowance as punishment isn't good, Boelter says. Children should learn the consequences of
their behavior or poor decisions in more appropriate ways. If you dock their allowance they'll ask
for more money anyway, she points out. When kids misbehave, it's better to make the discipline fit
the deed than to dock their allowance.
Parents should at least have a responsibility for basic living expenses. Beyond that, a child's
income from jobs and allowances needs to be negotiated and clearly understood between parents and
children. You are helping kids learn how to handle money and make informed decisions. "Allowance
isn't a one-size-fits-all issue and it's something parents and children alike will need to work
through," says Boelter. "The important thing is communication--that's how kids learn these skills."
Home & Family Finance Online article:
- "Dollars & Sense for Kids," by Janet Bodnar, Kiplinger's Washington Editors Inc., 1999 (ISBN
- "The Kid's Guide to Money: Earning It, Saving It, Spending It, Growing It, Sharing It," by Steve
Otfinoski, Scholastic Inc., 1996 (ISBN 0590538535)
- "The Kids' Allowance Book," by Amy Nathan, Walker Publishing Company Inc., 1998 (ISBN 0802775322)
- "Kids and Money: Giving Them the Savvy to Succeed Financially," by Jayne A. Pearl, Bloomberg Press,
1999 (ISBN 1576600645)
Home & Family FinanceŽ Resource Center
Copyright © 1997-2013 Credit Union National Association Inc.